Payday alternative loans (PALs): credit union rules and costs
Credit union payday alternative loans cap APR at 28% and fees at $20, with no rollovers. PAL I vs PAL II rules, a worked example, and how to find one.
In this article 6 sections
A payday alternative loan, or PAL, is a small loan that federal credit unions are allowed to make to their members under a special federal rule. It exists for exactly the moment a payday loan is sold for: you need a few hundred dollars before your next paycheck. The difference is the price and the shape. A PAL is capped at 28% APR, the application fee can't exceed $20, it can't be rolled over, and it is repaid in installments over one to twelve months instead of in one lump on payday.
The rules are short and specific. They sit in the National Credit Union Administration's lending regulation, 12 CFR 701.21(c)(7)(iii) and (iv)1, and every number below comes from that text or from the NCUA itself. There are two versions, PAL I and PAL II, and a credit union picks which to offer.
What is a payday alternative loan?
It is a closed-end installment loan from a federal credit union, priced above the credit union's normal rate ceiling but far below payday rates. The regulation lets a federal credit union charge "1000 basis points above the maximum interest rate established by the Board"1 as long as the loan follows the PAL conditions.
The regulation's general maximum is 15% a year, but the NCUA Board can set a higher temporary ceiling, and it has: on Feb 6, 2026, it extended an 18% ceiling to Sep 10, 20272. Add 1,000 basis points (10 percentage points) and you get the PAL cap the NCUA states directly: "The current loan interest rate ceiling on PALs is 28 percent."3
The regulation also requires that every PAL be "fully amortized". Each payment covers interest and some principal, so the balance falls with every installment and the loan ends on a set date. A payday loan works the other way: you owe the whole amount plus the fee on one day, and if you can't pay it all, many states let the lender renew it for another fee while the principal stays where it was. Our post on how payday loans work shows how that chain forms.
What are the PAL I and PAL II rules?
Both versions share the 28% cap, the $20 fee cap and the ban on rollovers. They differ on size, length and how long you must be a member first. These are the conditions in 12 CFR 701.21(c)(7)(iii)–(iv)1, set beside a typical payday loan as the CFPB describes it.
| PAL I | PAL II | Typical payday loan | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amount | $200 to $1,000 | Up to $2,000 (no minimum) | Usually $500 or less |
| Term | 1 to 6 months | 1 to 12 months | Due in one payment, usually 2 to 4 weeks |
| Membership before you can borrow | At least 1 month | No waiting period | None |
| Price cap | 28% APR | 28% APR | Set by state; $15 per $100 is common (almost 400% APR) |
| Application fee | $20 at most | $20 at most | Fee is the price of the loan |
| Rollovers | Banned | Banned | Allowed in some states |
| How many | One at a time; no more than three in any rolling six months | Set by state law, if at all | |
| Overdraft or NSF fees tied to the loan | Not addressed | Banned | Your bank's fees apply if a debit bounces |
Payday column: CFPB, What is a payday loan?8 and CFPB, What are the costs and fees for a payday loan?7
The details that matter
- The fee. The rule calls for "a reasonable application fee" that "reflects the actual costs associated with processing the application, but that in no case exceeds $20." It is charged to every applicant, which is why Regulation Z leaves it out of the finance charge6 and so out of the quoted APR. Count it anyway when you compare costs; we do in the example below.
- Extensions. The rollover ban has one narrow exception: the credit union may stretch the term within the maximum (six months for PAL I, twelve for PAL II) if it charges no extra fee and lends no extra money. If you're struggling to make a payment, ask about that first.
- The overdraft protection in PAL II. A credit union making a PAL II may not charge "a fee or charge, including a non-sufficient funds fee" under its overdraft service in connection with the loan.
- Underwriting. The credit union must have underwriting guidelines "such as, requiring a borrower to verify employment by providing at least two recent pay stubs." The NCUA's guidance suggests looking at your account history and proof of recurring income rather than a credit score, but each credit union sets its own standards.
PAL II came later. The NCUA Board approved it on Sep 19, 20194, adding the larger amount, the longer term and the option to lend right after someone joins, while keeping the original PAL program in place.
How much does a PAL cost compared with a payday loan?
Much less, even after the application fee. Here is $400 borrowed both ways. The PAL figures are standard amortization at the 28% cap over three monthly payments; the payday figures use the CFPB's common fee of $15 per $100.
- PAL, $400 over three months at 28%: three payments of about $139.60. Interest comes to about $18.81. Add the maximum $20 application fee and the total cost is about $38.81.
- Payday loan, $400 for two weeks at $15 per $100: $60 in fees, with $460 due in one payment on your next payday.
- The same payday loan renewed for twelve weeks, where state law allows renewals: six fees of $60 is $360, and the $400 is still owed at the end.
The renewal scenario isn't far-fetched. The CFPB's 2014 study of payday loans9 found that over 80% were rolled over or followed by another loan within 14 days, and that half of all loans sat in sequences of ten or more. A PAL can't do that: there is no rollover, and the three-loans-in-six-months limit caps how often you can come back.
A larger PAL II costs more in dollars because you borrow more for longer: $2,000 over twelve months at 28% is about $316 in interest. Compare that with the alternatives in our payday loan alternatives post before you borrow the maximum.
How do you find a credit union that offers PALs?
Fewer offer them than you might expect. NCUA call report data as of Sep 30, 2025 shows 467 federal credit unions reporting that they offer PALs3, with program balances totalling $139 million. Many credit unions make other small loans instead, under their own names and terms, so the question to ask is about the loan, not the label.
- Start with credit unions you can already join. Every credit union has a field of membership: an employer, a community, a school, a military connection, a church or association, or a relative who is already a member. Your employer's benefits page and your local community credit union are the usual places to start.
- Search the NCUA's list. The NCUA Credit Union Locator5 lets you look up federally insured credit unions by name and location.
- Call and ask three questions. Do you offer payday alternative loans (PAL I or PAL II), or another small-dollar loan? What is the APR and the application fee? How long must I be a member, and what documents do you need?
- Join before you need the money, if you can. A PAL I requires a month of membership. A PAL II doesn't, but the credit union still has to approve you and fund the loan, which isn't always same day.
What about state-chartered credit unions?
The PAL rules are part of the NCUA's lending regulation for federal credit unions; § 701.21 "generally applies to Federal credit unions only"1. A state-chartered credit union follows its state's lending laws, and many make their own small-dollar loans on different terms. Those can be good loans too, but the 28% cap, the $20 fee limit and the rollover ban don't automatically apply, so read the disclosure and ask for the APR.
Who can't get a PAL, and what are the downsides?
A PAL is the cheapest regulated small loan most people can get, but it isn't always available, and it isn't always the fastest.
- Membership is required. If no credit union near you takes you, or none of those that do offers a PAL, it isn't an option.
- There is underwriting. Credit unions must verify your ability to repay in some way, typically with pay stubs or deposit history. A payday lender may ask for less, which is part of why it charges so much more.
- Speed varies. Some credit unions fund online in a day; others need a branch visit. If the bill is due tomorrow, a hardship plan or an employer pay advance may bridge the gap until the PAL arrives.
- Limits on repeat use. Three PALs in any rolling six months, one at a time. That is a safeguard, not a flaw, but it means a PAL can't cover a gap that recurs every pay period.
- It is still debt. Missing payments can bring late fees and damage your credit if the credit union reports to the bureaus. The NCUA's guidance encourages credit unions to report PAL payments, which can help your credit when you pay on time.
If a credit union loan isn't possible, our comparison of cash advance apps and payday loans covers the next cheapest option for small, short gaps. If you're already in a payday loan you can't repay, read how to get out of payday loan debt first: some states require lenders to offer a no-cost payment plan, and a PAL used to pay off a payday loan only helps if it ends the cycle.
Can a PAL be used to pay off a payday loan?
Yes. The rules don't restrict what you use the money for, and replacing a loan priced near 400% APR with one capped at 28% cuts the cost sharply. Two cautions. First, a PAL I tops out at $1,000 and a PAL II at $2,000, so check that it covers the full payoff amount, including any fee due. Second, once the payday loan is paid, revoke its authorization to debit your account in writing, so the lender can't pull a payment you no longer owe; the CFPB's steps are in our debt guide.
Rules last checked Nov 21, 2026. The 18% ceiling, and with it the 28% PAL cap, is set by the NCUA Board and is due to be reviewed again before Sep 10, 20272.
Sources
- 12 CFR 701.21(c)(7)(iii)–(iv): payday alternative loans (PALs I and II), eCFR ecfr.gov
- NCUA: Board extends loan interest rate ceiling (Feb 6, 2026) ncua.gov
- NCUA: Permissible loan interest rate ceiling extended, supplemental information (call report data as of Sep 30, 2025) ncua.gov
- NCUA: Payday alternative loan rule will create more alternatives for borrowers (Sep 19, 2019) ncua.gov
- NCUA: Credit Union Locator mapping.ncua.gov
- 12 CFR 1026.4(c)(1): application fees charged to all applicants are not finance charges, eCFR ecfr.gov
- CFPB: What are the costs and fees for a payday loan? (last reviewed Nov 25, 2024) consumerfinance.gov
- CFPB: What is a payday loan? consumerfinance.gov
- CFPB Data Point: Payday Lending (March 2014) files.consumerfinance.gov
Facts last checked November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at editor@paydayloans.now.